Mr. Girl's critic of Dr. K. Thoughts?

[Danioover9000]

@Max_V

2 hours ago, Max_V said:

@Danioover9000 Ah, I don't know. I thought he was speaking about the fact that he tried to kill himself at 16 when his favourite game closed down. 

   I might've guessed wrong, I thought @Leo Gura was talking about the last video between Reckfull and Dr. K, and whatever happened between the time he and Dr. k logged off, and before his suicide, that something happened with his game, and Reckfull's vision being limited.

[SOUL]

37 minutes ago, Danioover9000 said:

Very good post and points. My issue with Dr. K, when he brought up the predictive Doshas and how they can predict the likelihood of one getting Covid, is that he was saying it in such an open way, without giving written and/or verbal disclaimers about this shouldn't be a substitute for Covid precautions and treatments

I haven't watched all of DrK's videos but the only instance I've seen of him mentioning ayurvedic ideas, that dosha stuff, and covid is when he said his colleagues in India were able to predict the COMPLICATIONS associated with covid, not whether someone will get it or not or whether they will die or not.

My assumption would be that these colleagues were looking at patients who already had covid, were using the dosha types to make a prediction of what complications the patient would experience and then seeing how accurate those predictions were.  Who knows if true but DrK doesn't appear to be making any medical recommendations from it.

I'm not advocating for or against it and sure I have no desire to spread pseudo science or misinformation but I also see accusations that don't match up with what I see going on. There are fair criticisms to make but it doesn't help to exaggerate or fabricate just to make them. Not accusing you just pointing out it seems to be happening.

[Danioover9000]

@SOUL

On 3/1/2022 at 8:34 PM, SOUL said:

I haven't watched all of DrK's videos but the only instance I've seen of him mentioning ayurvedic ideas, that dosha stuff, and covid is when he said his colleagues in India were able to predict the COMPLICATIONS associated with covid, not whether someone will get it or not or whether they will die or not.

My assumption would be that these colleagues were looking at patients who already had covid, were using the dosha types to make a prediction of what complications the patient would experience and then seeing how accurate those predictions were.  Who knows if true but DrK doesn't appear to be making any medical recommendations from it.

I'm not advocating for or against it and sure I have no desire to spread pseudo science or misinformation but I also see accusations that don't match up with what I see going on. There are fair criticisms to make but it doesn't help to exaggerate or fabricate just to make them. Not accusing you just pointing out it seems to be happening.

   Fair enough. I was pointing out the implications.

[Danioover9000]

   Another great breakdown of Dr. K's ethics video:

 

Edited March 4, 2022 by Danioover9000