What is logic ?

[Majed]

Very profound question. Here's an insight: logic is equation. What do you think ? 

[James123]

2 minutes ago, Majed said:

Very profound question. Here's an insight: logic is equation. What do you think ? 

Logic is balance for survival. 

[Aaron p]

Three examples of basic logic: 

### 1. **Everyday Decision-Making:**

   - **Situation:** Deciding whether to take an umbrella when leaving the house.

   - **Logic in Action:** If the sky is cloudy and the weather forecast says there’s a 90% chance of rain, it’s logical to take the umbrella to avoid getting wet.

   - **Why It Matters:** Logic helps us make practical, efficient choices by weighing evidence and predicting outcomes.

 

### 2. **Moral Reasoning:**

   - **Situation:** Deciding whether to tell the truth even if it might hurt someone’s feelings.

   - **Logic in Action:** Honesty builds trust and respect, even if it’s uncomfortable in the moment. Lying might avoid short-term pain but can harm relationships in the long run.

   - **Why It Matters:** Logic guides ethical decisions by evaluating consequences and aligning actions with principles like integrity and fairness.

 

### 3. **Scientific Discovery:**

   - **Situation:** A scientist testing whether a new medicine works.

   - **Logic in Action:** If the medicine consistently improves patients’ health in controlled experiments and no other factors explain the results, it’s logical to conclude the medicine is effective.

   - **Why It Matters:** Logic is the backbone of science, helping us uncover truths about the world by systematically testing ideas and drawing reliable conclusions.

 

In each case, logic is a tool for clarity, whether in practical choices, ethical dilemmas, or uncovering truths about the universe. It’s about connecting the dots to make sense of the world.

 

Three examples of the limitations of logic: 

### 1. **Emotional and Human Complexity:**

   - **Situation:** Deciding whether to end a troubled relationship.

   - **Limitation of Logic:** While logic might suggest ending the relationship if it’s causing more harm than good, emotions like love, attachment, and hope complicate the decision. Logic can’t fully account for the depth of human feelings or the nuances of personal history.

   - **Why It Matters:** Logic struggles to navigate situations where emotions, intuition, and subjective experiences play a central role.

 

### 2. **Paradoxes and Unresolvable Problems:**

   - **Situation:** The "liar paradox" (e.g., "This statement is false").

   - **Limitation of Logic:** If the statement is true, then it must be false, and if it’s false, then it must be true. Logic can’t resolve this contradiction because it creates an infinite loop.

   - **Why It Matters:** Some problems are inherently unsolvable within logical systems, revealing the boundaries of reason.

 

### 3. **Mysteries of Existence:**

   - **Situation:** Questions like "What is the meaning of life?" or "Why does the universe exist?"

   - **Limitation of Logic:** These questions go beyond what logic can address because they involve concepts that are abstract, infinite, or beyond human comprehension. Logic relies on evidence and reasoning, but these questions often lack definitive answers or frameworks to analyze.

   - **Why It Matters:** Logic is limited when grappling with existential or metaphysical questions that transcend empirical observation and rational thought.

 

In each case, logic hits a wall—whether it’s the messiness of human emotions, unsolvable paradoxes, or the profound mysteries of existence. These limitations remind us that while logic is a powerful tool, it’s not always sufficient to fully understand or navigate the complexities of life. 

 

Other available avenues and methodologies available in the pursuit of finding answers when logic fails: 

When logic falls short in answering profound or complex questions, other methods and approaches can be employed to explore and seek understanding. These methods often complement logic by tapping into different ways of knowing and experiencing the world. Here are three key alternatives:

 

---

 

### 1. **Intuition and Inner Wisdom:**

   - **What It Is:** Intuition is a deep, often subconscious sense of knowing that doesn’t rely on step-by-step reasoning. It’s like a "gut feeling" or an inner compass.

   - **How It Helps:** For questions like "What should I do with my life?" or "What is my purpose?", intuition can guide decisions based on personal values, desires, and a sense of alignment with one’s deeper self.

   - **Example:** An artist might feel drawn to create a certain piece of work without being able to logically explain why—it just feels "right."

   - **Why It Works:** Intuition taps into accumulated experiences, emotions, and subconscious insights that logic can’t always access.

 

---

 

### 2. **Experience and Embodied Knowledge:**

   - **What It Is:** Learning through direct experience, practice, and immersion in life rather than abstract reasoning.

   - **How It Helps:** For questions like "What is love?" or "How do I find happiness?", logic can only go so far. True understanding often comes from living through experiences, feeling emotions, and reflecting on them.

   - **Example:** You can’t fully understand what it means to be a parent by reading about it—you have to live it.

   - **Why It Works:** Experience provides a visceral, firsthand understanding that logic alone cannot replicate.

 

---

 

### 3. **Mystical or Spiritual Insight:**

   - **What It Is:** A transcendent way of knowing that often arises from meditation, prayer, contemplation, or moments of profound connection with something greater than oneself.

   - **How It Helps:** For questions like "What is the nature of reality?" or "Is there a higher purpose?", spiritual practices can offer insights that logic cannot. These insights often come as moments of clarity, awe, or unity with the universe.

   - **Example:** A mystic might experience a sense of oneness with all things during deep meditation, providing an answer to existential questions that logic cannot fully articulate.

   - **Why It Works:** Spiritual insight bypasses the limitations of the rational mind, offering a direct, experiential connection to deeper truths.

 

---

 

### Bonus: **Art, Creativity, and Symbolism:**

   - **What It Is:** Using creative expression—like art, music, poetry, or storytelling—to explore and communicate truths that logic cannot fully capture.

   - **How It Helps:** For questions like "What does it mean to be human?" or "How do I process grief?", art can convey emotions, paradoxes, and complexities that logic struggles to articulate.

   - **Example:** A poem about loss might capture the depth of sorrow in a way that a logical analysis never could.

   - **Why It Works:** Creativity taps into the symbolic, emotional, and imaginative dimensions of human experience.

 

---

 

### Final Thought:

When logic isn’t enough, these alternative methods—intuition, experience, spiritual insight, and creativity—offer pathways to understanding that are equally valid and often more holistic. They remind us that not all truths can be reasoned; some must be felt, lived, or glimpsed through moments of transcendence. Together, these approaches provide a richer, more complete way of engaging with life’s deepest questions.

[Hojo]

2 words

[Carl-Richard]

Logic is an attempt at putting pure structure into words.

Edited Friday at 05:46 AM by Carl-Richard

[Letho]

@Majed Yeah that's an interesting take. I think 'logic' has a multifaceted gestalt that many peoples ideas here could contribute to, equation being one; what encloses an equation though to add one neat thread to said gestalt is, 'Logic is self-referentiality'.  For example, causality reflects this notion of self-referentiality, though another one is 'patterns'. For example, '544333222211111', I'm sure you see the pattern, in this sense, the action of both creating a pattern and observing a pattern have two different kinds of 'self-referential action'. I'll stop there though.

Peace and hope you share with us that greater integrated gestalt later on brother!

 

[Breakingthewall]

Logic is the understanding of the structure of reality, which is synchronous. Being synchronous, it must follow some rules, since any deviation would cause asynchrony and therefore non-existence.

Einstein said that the strangest thing about reality is that it is understandable, but it is not strange, it is logical, since reality must be perfectly synchronized with itself to be able to manifest, otherwise it would not manifest.

There is no need for a creator for gravity to be exactly what it is, since if it were even the slightest bit different, the synchrony would be broken and the entire reality would collapse and disappear, or rather, it would never have appeared. If it appears it is because it is absolutely synchronic, not because someone decides that it should be that way, but because this possibility is possible.

[Yimpa]

Logic is discovering that 1+1=10 in a certain context

[gettoefl]

Logic is a house of cards. The relationships you formulate will work then not work. Be successful with your logic and watch it tumble down. Perfection cannot be. Until you go home.

[Salvijus]

18 hours ago, Majed said:

logic is equation. What do you think ? 

Sounds logical. 

I would've said "an accurate equivalent"

[WonderSeeker]

Structuralism = God

Logic = Jesus

[Atb210201]

Logic is honesty with yourself.

[Florian]

I think logic is what defines relative truth and creates order

[Atb210201]

Logic is seeking Truth.