Here Is Little Question For You.

[Parki]

Can a shadow clash to another shadow and make a sound by it?

[Evilwave Heddy]

...what?

[Tibor]

1 hour ago, Parki said:

Can a shadow clash to another shadow and make a sound by it?

Depends what you difine as sound

 

[Parki]

@Dingus what? I am not high, bro.

Do you know this koan:"You can clap with two hands, but what the clap of one hand"?
I wanted to ask you sorta like this,
but my English is fucked so no one understand what am I talking about.
I mean you can take two physical objects and clash one into another and you probably will hear a loud sound by making this.
You can do this with physical objects, but can you do the same with shadows?

[cetus]

1 hour ago, Parki said:

Can a shadow clash to another shadow and make a sound by it?

Yes. And two sounds can also clash and create a shadow.

[Tibor]

@Dingus

1 minute ago, Dingus said:

What you're really wondering is, how can physical objects produce sound if they don't really exist. Right?

And if they don't produce the sound, then what does, and why.

If two objects collaide and they produce a sound if they dont exist then does the sound exist.

Everything is energy constantly flowing so energy collaiding can produce sound or even a sound which is not in youre hearing range.

But what si a sound really?

[Parki]

@Tibor I mean the experience of a sound. Just snap with your fingers.

[Prabhaker]

2 hours ago, Parki said:

Can a shadow clash to another shadow and make a sound by it?

Remember, they are shadows. They are, in a sense, and still they are not: that is the meaning of a shadow. It is non-substantial. A shadow is just an absence. If someone says that the shadow is a reality, that darkness is a reality, he is right.  Although darkness exists, shadow exists, nevertheless it is only the absence of light. Clash of shadows don't make sound. 

@Parki Can clash of two light beams make a sound ?

[Parki]

@Dingus

I didn't see that coming...
I thought that everyone will be like:
"Shadows can't clash! only objects can, because shadows doesn't really exist,
they just a projection of a real object."
And then I would be like:
"No actually shadows can clash too! Just look at your hand's shadows and clap with them.
See? A shadow can clash to another shadow and make a sound by it! That's a fact, you can't deny it!"
And then you would be like:
"No shadows can't clash it just how it appears to you.
The object are clashing but you look at the shadow and think that it's the origianl object!"
And then I would be like:
"But how do you know that the physical object is the origianl object, not just another shadow?"

You humans are bad today cuz you destroyed my genious plan.

[Staples]

Let me know if I'm on your train of thought here,

A shadow is an illusion of a physical thing (a darkening on a surface) but it really isn't physical because it's just the absence of light. 
So you're trying to connect that to the clash of hands and the sound it makes, and you're saying that is an illusion as well?

They're two different flavors of illusion, a shadow is a confirmed illusion as it is an absence of something. A hand is an unconfirmed illusion because it is not an absence, it is made up of matter yet has illusory aspects to it like "that is my hand", "that is someone else's hand", "I call this thing a hand" etc.

One is conceptual the other is "physical" but projected.

[FirstglimpseOMG]

Let's go further. You are everything that you perceive. In fact you create it as you go. Femto-second by femto-second. The light that illuminates the object, the object, all the qualia of that object, and the body-mind that interacts with itself as creation. 

As long as we're keeping it simple and not counter-intuitive at all, you know...

[abrakamowse]

Awesome question @Parki  This is good for inquiring about the nature of reality.

When I am meditating I am questioning about what is a thought, if it has weight, color, smell? etc... hehehe...

 

[Dodo]

On 16/04/2017 at 11:11 AM, Parki said:

Can a shadow clash to another shadow and make a sound by it?

no (except the sound of silence) 

Edited April 19, 2017 by Dodoster