Carl-Richard

Member
  • Content count

    17,731
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Carl-Richard

  1. First, a definition of terms: Simple = not complex. Complexity is many interacting things, simplicity is few interacting things. Easy = not hard. Hardness is the difficulty with which something is performed, easiness is the lightness with which something is performed. We might tend to say something is simple but not easy if we can imagine and describe the general task in simple terms but the execution is not easy. This might be more true for some problems, for example lifting a heavy object. The task of lifting it up is thought to be simple and it's the weight of the object that makes it hard. But for other problems, this might be less true. For example, I'm currently filling door cracks with rubber for isolating the doors. I wanted to describe it to myself as "simple but not easy", but I realized that the actions for filling them is actually not simple. Sometimes it's really hard to make the rubber fit inside the crack, and the reason for this might be complex: the exact size and width of the crack might vary along the length of the door frame, the exact properties of the rubber might vary due to production processes and inhomogeneity of the material. It's just that when we usually describe the task, we tend to ignore that level of detail and simply describe it as "fitting the rubber inside the crack". It's a bit like describing football (soccer) as "getting the ball inside the net". It's of course a bit more complex than that. So the complexity is underdetermined in our description of the problem and we outsource its hidden complexity to its hardness, "it's simple but hard". There might also be hidden complexity in the lifting heavy object example, but here the complexity might even be more hidden as it's perhaps harder to describe in principle (and we just pack that complexity as a simple description, "biology").
  2. "Evolved" might not be the right frame. It's the case that schizotypy (let's call it "fluidity of consciousness") exists as a trait in the population and some people exist at the extremes such that it makes functioning quite difficult. Schizotypy is essentially associated with making associations (at the extremes "tangentiality" and "thought disorder") and unusual perceptual experiences (at the extremes e.g. hallucinations). The thing is that as schizotypy increases, working memory, IQ, general cognitive functioning, generally decreases (schizophrenics tend to fall in this category). Genius is typically associated with a high degree of general cognitive functioning and some level of schizotypy.
  3. I barely do myself. It was a joke 🫠
  4. 🤣 It wasn't a bad score, it was the same as me. You think I would imply my own score is bad? 😀😀 But yeah, IQ tests are IQ tests. Or rather shady online IQ tests are shady online IQ tests. The real IQ test is probably life.
  5. I have not taken an official test where you book an appointment with a psychometrician or Mensa. There was a thread where a bunch of people took a test and shared their scores and I got a good score on some facets (I believe the best one was called something like the "spatial" facet, perhaps partially due to my N-Back training) but I can't find it, maybe it is hidden (maybe Leo hid it because he was embarrassed of his score 😂 Jk; me and Leo scored the same score overall — but one of the facets for me was much lower than the others and I think it had to do with it being a vocabulary test and it used some absolutely arcane words I've never heard of and I'm not a native English speaker so that's maybe why or maybe it used words more common in fiction literature while I'm more used to non-fiction). Alright I'll share the score: the overall score was 124, the highest was 145 or 146, the lowest was 116 or something (or even 109? 103?), the others (or "other") were 134, 130, there about. If I had been a vocabulary genius (to be honest, that's a shit thing to base your IQ on; it's mainly crystallized intelligence), maybe the overall would've been 130s+. I can do more shilling for N-Back training if you'd like >:]
  6. We don't know that, and if true, to what degree. What is known is that comparing a pattern against a template requires holding things in working memory, updating, manipulating, discarding, etc. What we also know is that a comprehensive IQ test tries to test many different domains and kinds of mental operations, and that in aggregate, the contribution of each specific domain lessens and the more general mechanisms become more salient. And of course, the general workspace of the mind, the working memory, approximates such a mechanism. https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn1201 "Fluid intelligence" is what IQ is trying to test (along with crystallized intelligence). It has been shown to make you perform better on IQ tests. Whether IQ can be said to capture "intelligence" is of course a different question. Also, the particular literature on N-back training seems to be underdetermined mainly due to the problem of assigning participants to your study (they tend to be not very motivated to perform well, not knowledgeable about what they're doing or seeking out knowledge or mentorship/advice, not seriously aiming to improve, less likely to actually be consistent or engage with high focus or intensity). You should expect greater effects if you're motivated, informed/educated, engaged (and people do anecdotally report great changes in their day to day life and also on IQ tests, e.g. 13 IQ points after a year of training). I believe most people underestimate especially how sprint training in particular affects cognition. Lactate is something the brain responds to in a very interesting way (besides the act of pushing the ceiling of intensity of your physiology, seems to have a direct mirror in your psychology, in that you're able to do more intense cognitive operations, which would at least affect working memory particularly well). As for "a couple of points", a couple of IQ points is a lot considering an increase from 115 (most college graduates) to 120 pushes you from top 16% to top 9% of people. Comparable to going from a B to an A. If you're even higher than that, e.g. 136, and increase it to 149 (13 points), like one anecdote, you go from already gifted to genius level. The kinds of things you can do at that level and the compounding effects over time are definitely not to be discarded.
  7. The point is not to reduce it down to one thing and nothing else. It's to ask what is the thing that most explains it. Creativity could impact IQ test performance (it does), but it's not as central. The thing about working memory is that it underlies all mental operations. Every test you ever do involves working memory. So tests for reasoning and pattern recognition do actually test working memory, and it's not possible to really control for it. You can make so-called tests for approximating pure working memory (e.g. digit span tests, N-back), but you can never really control for the working memory component of each "non-working memory" test (you could do it half-assedly by giving multiple different cognitive tests at once, but then you're disproportionately controlling for some things over others unless you manage to give enough tests to capture the entire human psyche). So how much of each test is due to working memory or how much is due to the particular test is actually not that easy to determine. You can really only go by logical inference and what is most likely the case. What we do know is that things like N-back training (which is again thought to approximate pure working memory) increase IQ, things like physical activity (particularly high-intensity cardiovascular and power/speed training) and optimal diet and pharmaceuticals (e.g. amphetamines). So basic things that increase the baseline functioning, metabolic capacity, bloodflow, etc., do increase IQ, and do so in a rate-dependent way (more bloodflow or energy to the brain does not necessarily make you a completely different person, just sharper, quicker, clearer). And when you do try to make tests for approximating pure working memory (again like N-back), we see that this tends to correlate with IQ around 0.50-0.80, which is a moderate to very strong correlation (0.90-0.95 is more or less the maximum you would expect before you start to suspect statistical problems). And even if some other tests could score higher, again, how much of that is working memory and how much of that is something else? So working memory is the basis of all mental operations, you can't really control for its effects properly using tests, and when you try to make tests for working memory, they correlate strongly with IQ, and IQ tests have built-in incentives for speed (time pressure) and for completing a large number of tasks (usually around 100), and we see that physiological rate-dependent factors do increase IQ.
  8. Sure those are obvious. Reasoning towards an answer, finding patterns, definitely a part of general problem-solving/intelligence and what IQ tries to capture. But consider how much pattern recognition and reasoning depends on identifying and weighing options, testing comparisons, etc. If you do that faster and at a larger quantity, that will significantly impact your reasoning and pattern recognition skills (certainly in a timed scenario like an IQ test). If you have a lousy CPU that only does two comparisons a minute, you can be the best reasonmaker and pattern finder and you won't make it out the first base before the game is over. And as far as operationalizing pattern recognition and reasoning skills, you would do it through something like an IQ test which you would likely time or else it would be hard to standardize the results, and then you would of course end up at working memory capacity being a central piece again. You can also question whether there are any significant rate-independent factors for these things. If for example 100 IQ gives you 15 comparisons a minute but 160 IQ gives you 150, that's going to produce astronomically different results. I believe it was Jordan Peterson who said that high IQ individuals are so much more productive than normal IQ people that it's mind-boggling. If the main difference is the rate of basic cognitive operations, that wouldn't be too mysterious. But I think there are rate-independent factors (certain minds just tend to work in certain particular ways), but again, they're probably hard to measure/operationalize in a way that separates them from the rate-dependent ones.
  9. Yes. The speed and size of your cognitive conveyor belt, your working memory capacity (mental working space). Your cognition can be thought to have a basic engine that determines how fast you process units of information and how many units of information you can hold in your cognition at once. The way IQ tests are constructed (time pressure × amount of tasks completed) and the relatively simple nature of the tasks means it largely approximates this function.
  10. Statistically, no. I've by the way made the case why Ne and Ti could outperform Ni and Te (and feeling and sensing functions). And by the way, I tried to deduce it from first principles rather than trying to retrospectively explain the graphic you presented (even though I have seen the graphic before): Of course, in reality every person uses every function. It's just they prefer some over others. Somebody who matches most closely ESFJ could still be relatively fast even if they don't prefer thinking and intuition functions. It's just statistically, you won't see the extremes as much in those types.
  11. Ever since I started meditating, I always found it funny. ">:( go away, I'm trying to be 'spiritual' over here". By the way, the character is a recluse monk in the woods who a more worldly monk tells you to talk to for help during a quest. I.e., he has not yet taken the vow of the bodhisattva and is stuck perhaps only intermittently indulging in meditative states, as that is often the case when you are principally opposed to the world which is yourself.
  12. There is essentially nothing you do that doesn't involve your IQ. It's just you can have a relatively normal IQ and be highly skilled for example due to a lot of practice or other personal dispositions. But IQ was always in some way involved in acquiring that skill. IQ means you will acquire skills faster (but not necessarily become exceptional; that tends to depend again on other personal dispositions relevant to that skill or developing skills in general). It's a weird example but the OSRS streamer "Odablock" is a good example of how you can be exceptionally skilled without a necessarily exceptional IQ. He has for example always been somebody who refines his performance based on past behavior in a very diligent way (he rewatches past performances and identifies mistakes and corrects them). This is untrue. Some people with autism tend to have high IQ and those might struggle with social situations, but that's not due to their IQ. High IQ people without autism tend to be extremely well-adapted socially. And you would expect that to be the case, because their IQ helps them in that. Again, there is essentially nothing IQ doesn't touch. It's central to information processing. Of course IQ combined with very high general openness for example can make it harder to identify with certain things or people, but that would be due to your extreme openness and not your IQ. If you're relatively pragmatic and concerned about everyday happenings, having a high IQ just means you will tend to fly through those things. My stepdad is like that. He doesn't think for example talking about health is in any way worth his time (he is not interested in it merely from seeing connections and being curious), but he will start and complete projects faster than you'll probably ever see. I would say Langan's so-called tribulations are due to his personality and environment growing up and not his IQ.
  13. Thing is if your IQ is low enough, you can't keep a single coherent sentence in mind at one time. Scale that up and you'll see that maybe a high IQ is not such a bad idea. There are a few people you'll meet that are noticeably "slow" in the way they think and talk and you get a sense of unclarity, and they might even come off like they have dementia (which is effectively equivalent with a low IQ or generally low cognitive functioning).
  14. That's not the point. IQ tests something. That it's called "intelligence quotient" is of course a stupid thing everything considered. Complexity, creativity, subtlety, intuition, logicality/coherence, connectivity/associative ability (latent inhibition); many things not as directly measured by IQ can impact what we would consider to be "intelligence".
  15. Again, you can make a good case it tests thinking speed and general "quantitative" capacity. It's not any more shallow than assigning a color to somebody's cultural inclinations (Spiral Dynamics). "These types of people tend to think fast and work through a lot of information in a short time". It's very insightful.
  16. A timed test where you do tasks that tend to stress load-bearing capacities related to working memory (how many numbers, shapes, things, can you hold and manipulate in your mind at once, in sequence; how many comparisons, relationships, patterns/connections can you test). For example, rotating a shape in your mind and see if it fits a template, doing that multiple times with multiple possible options, over time. You start to see that we're testing some basic "quantitative" ability. "But rotating shapes is dumb". Yes, but rotating many different shapes successfully in quick succession over time (and other dumb tasks like that), tells you that you mind probably does this with many different things, like concepts, words, whatever cognitive unit you can think of. Now again, this is different from thinking complex thoughts. IQ and complexity are not the same. IQ is again more like quantity (how many simple OR complex units, how quickly do you process them).
  17. In other words, not knowing what IQ means means you will assume things about IQ that might not be accurate.
  18. If you know what an IQ test is and you have the "IQ" to know/estimate how it could generalize and how it would probably not generalize, then you're probably better off knowing about that than not. The main thing I've gathered from people you could consider high IQ, is you get the sense that they are very "quick". There was a girl once in university who I wanted to tell once while working in a group project "something tells me you have a high IQ". Because she was just so very quick with what we were doing. And only later I found out she had been in the newspaper described as one of the best math heads in the country and competing in math competitions when younger. Another group project in a different university; same story, different person, and she actually shared her IQ (Mensa member). It was a bit cringe that she shared it, but she was quick. One time we were doing a group presentation and one of the group members pussed out and she learned their part on the day maybe an hour or so before the presentation and she presented it so smoothly as if she had written it herself. Another girl from uni who also is very quick I know has applied for a PhD position and is ranked in the leading positions for consideration to the position and is very fresh out of her graduate degree. My graduate advisor (professor), very quick. My sort of stepdad is a professor in medicine, very quick. Mike Israetel (who boasts of 160 IQ), also very quick (he is probably a good example of the limits of IQ). My actual stepdad, very quick, top position in an oil company.
  19. I would even suggest that maximizing your IQ (which is a thing you can do) is another thing to have in mind. Let's not even call it IQ: let's just call it speed and capacity. Would you prefer to spend 50 seconds reading a few sentences or 5 seconds? 50 minutes working a task or 5 minutes with the same output? Be able to hold 8-9 numbers in your mind at once or 5? IQ closely maps on to such things. Basic load-bearing metrics.
  20. So that you know if you have high DPS or not?
  21. IQ is like the speed and size of your shovel. Shoveling through the snow of life, it helps you a lot. That doesn't mean you can't slide or find hills that bypasses the shoveling process. But a lot of problems involve shoveling. Metaphor aside, IQ is quantitative in that it deals with how much, how quick, how big, are the things you are putting inside your mind. It doesn't necessarily deal with how complex things are (that's cognitive complexity). An academic with 160 IQ can make a great normal scientist and teacher, but it does not necessarily make a Newton, an Einstein, a Ken Wilber, people who create the theories that people teach. That requires a certain complexity of mind (meta-systematic, paradigmatic, and upwards). Similarly, having a high IQ does not necessarily mean you will be spiritually inclined. But it can help you with processing things related to spirituality, in so far they involve processing capacity, speed, etc. In my opinion, spiritual giftedness correlates more with being refined, precise, and a bit of an obsessive person (perhaps "conscientiousness" in the more qualitative or feminine aspects).
  22. The answer was she had more complex answers to questions when young than those with dementia. And the implication is "complex cognition when young" -> less likely to fall under the threshold of dementia when old. Which is just like saying the closer you are to the bottom, the more likely you are to reach the bottom over time as you age. Which is like "duh". "Ravaged by disease" would mean markes like plaque buildup associated with things like Alzheimers or likely other reductionistic markers like that. But a brain capable of complex cognition riddled with plaques would of course be less behaviorally demented than one capable of less complex cognition with plaques. There are expectedly other things about that brain that can explain that (e.g. connectivity, metabolic capacity; basically anything that makes a brain work).
  23. So here you get to learn that when you give people a test that determines whether or not they pass a minimal baseline of cognitive function where you're otherwise given the label "dementia", if you start with higher cognitive functioning (or more specifically cognitive complexity) earlier in life, this might not happen as often as if you start lower. Of course the point she is making was in the larger context of showing the power of algorithms in her talk about algorithms, but the fact that you can package a clip in this way and people like it, tells you how much the delivery matters for how something is liked or not (and ironically perhaps the cognitive complexity of the average person and ironically about the power of algorithms). You can ask me about the speech I had in a birthday party about that lol. I felt I sucked at delivery so I felt my speech sucked during the speech. (But when I heard it back later, it wasn't really that bad. And that has been a pattern every time I've held a speech).
  24. AI expert vs AI user expert. Kinda "I would write my PhD about AI" vs "I would let my AI write my PhD" kinda deal.
  25. Politics, pragmatics. "God" is a poisoned word. "All of the world's great contemplative traditions maintain that fundamentally there is only spirit, there is only God, literally nothing else exists except God". There is an emphasis on the emptiness aspect of God in Buddhism. The bliss/love aspect, is seen as less central. Could it be that Buddhists are less likely to enter later stages of awakening often referred to as "God-consciousness" (where bliss and love are seen as core facets of God) due to this focus? Maybe. Does that mean Buddhists in principle are not at such a stage? Maybe not.