Hardkill

Member
  • Content count

    5,270
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Hardkill

  • Rank
    - - -

Personal Information

  • Gender
    Male
  1. I want to revisit something Leo said in his April 6, 2025 blog post, “How Right-Wing Dominates Social Media.” He argued that left-wing coalitions tend to engage in circular firing squads, whereas right-wing coalitions are much better at rallying around a common leader. I understand his reasoning regarding the ideological differences between Stage Green and Stage Blue. A lot of commentators and experts out there have talked about this too. One of the common sayings about this has been “Democrats Fall in Love, Republicans Fall in Line.” “Democrats fall in love” means Democratic voters have historically been portrayed as wanting candidates who genuinely inspire them, excite them, and reflect their ideals. When they aren't enthusiastic about a nominee, some may become disengaged, criticize the candidate, or stay home. “Republicans fall in line” means Republican voters have historically been portrayed as more willing to unite behind their party's nominee, even if that candidate wasn't their first choice, because they prioritize defeating Democrats and advancing conservative policies. However, I think the electoral evidence from the past decade, and especially from 2025 and 2026, seriously challenges the idea that the Left is inherently less capable of political unity than the Right. Consider the electoral record since 2017. Democrats achieved major victories in the 2017 off-year elections, the 2018 midterms, several important 2019 elections, the 2020 presidential election, and numerous races in the 2022 midterms and 2023 off-year elections. Republicans certainly had significant victories during that period, including in 2021 and particularly in the 2024 presidential election. They also regained the House in 2022. Nevertheless, by the end of 2023, even numerous Republican politicians and conservative commentators were openly complaining about how frequently their party had been losing competitive elections since 2017–2018. But the 2025 and 2026 elections provide particularly striking counterexamples to Leo's argument. In 2025, Democrats experienced substantial electoral success across the country, including decisive gubernatorial victories in Virginia and New Jersey, important judicial and legislative victories, and unusually strong performances in special elections. According to Brookings, Democrats outperformed their 2024 electoral baselines in 50 of 60 special elections examined by Democratic pollster Molly Murphy, with an average swing of approximately 13 percentage points. The Democratic overperformance continued into 2026. In an April analysis, Brookings found that Republicans had lost ground relative to their 2024 performances in every congressional special election it examined. And then came the November 2026 midterms. One of the most revealing developments was that Democratic voters appeared considerably more motivated to participate than many Republican-leaning voters. An NPR analysis published November 13 found that across six Southern states, turnout declined by approximately 26% in counties Trump won in 2024, compared with only 19% in counties Harris won. Those are county-level comparisons, not direct measurements of individual Republicans and Democrats. Nevertheless, they provide substantial evidence that Republican-leaning areas experienced greater turnout declines. An additional analysis reported by Stateline suggested that Republican-leaning voters staying home explained a substantial portion of the Democratic gains in several states. Furthermore, Democrats won across an extraordinarily broad ideological spectrum. The 2026 midterms produced victories for staunch progressives, mainstream liberals, and moderate Democrats. Candidates such as Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and Troy Jackson in Maine won alongside candidates such as Jon Ossoff in Georgia and Roy Cooper in North Carolina. According to Roll Call, at least 22 candidates endorsed by the moderate Blue Dog PAC won House elections, while the Congressional Progressive Caucus anticipated adding at least 25 members. This is a fascinating contrast with the idea that ideological disagreements necessarily prevent the Left from forming effective electoral coalitions. Progressives and centrists can strongly disagree about economic policy, healthcare reform, foreign policy, identity politics, and the direction of the Democratic Party. Yet many still demonstrate a willingness to vote for Democratic candidates who don't fully represent their preferred ideology. And conversely, many voters who strongly identify with Trump and the Republican Party apparently haven't felt sufficiently motivated to support other Republican candidates when Trump himself isn't on the ballot. To me, this really challenges the old saying that “Democrats fall in love, Republicans fall in line.” Democratic voters clearly don't always need to fall in love with their candidates to participate enthusiastically. And Republican voters don't always fall in line simply because they strongly dislike the Democratic Party. Now, I'm not arguing that the Left doesn't engage in destructive infighting. It certainly does. Nor am I suggesting that the Right is incapable of extraordinary electoral unity, as 2024 demonstrated. I'm also aware that the party controlling the White House generally faces an enthusiasm disadvantage during midterm elections. But I think we need to distinguish between three different things: Ideological unity: How much people agree with one another. Organizational unity: How effectively different factions cooperate. Electoral unity: Whether people actually turn out and support their coalition's candidates. A political movement can experience substantial ideological disagreement while remaining electorally unified. Likewise, a movement can appear extremely loyal to a single leader without consistently mobilizing its supporters in other elections. My broader point is that public ideological infighting is not necessarily evidence of weak electoral cohesion. The elections of 2017–2023 and especially 2025–2026 suggest that progressive and centrist voters can unite around common electoral objectives despite substantial differences. Meanwhile, Republican voters have repeatedly demonstrated that loyalty to Trump does not automatically translate into turnout for every Republican candidate. So, given the electoral record of the past decade, particularly the extraordinarily broad Democratic victories of 2025 and 2026, are Stage Green coalitions really inherently harder to hold together than Stage Blue coalitions? Or could it be that the Left's internal disagreements are simply more visible, while its capacity for electoral unity has been underestimated?
  2. VoteHub has now called it for her! Democrats will have 56 senate seats!
  3. Alaska has just elected the first Democratic governor since 1998!
  4. All outlets have now called the Mississippi Senate race for Scott Colom! He's now the very first Democrat to be elected to represent Mississippi in the U.S. Senate since John C. Stennis in 1982 and the very first black US senator of the state ever since about 140 years ago! Stennis was a true believer in racial segregationism. I bet he and every other white racist back then or any time before that in Mississippi would've lost their minds if they had witnessed this.
  5. CNN has projected that Democrat Scott Colom will defeat Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi's U.S. Senate race!
  6. Yes! She is like MTG. Also, that's another US House seat flipped for the Democrats!
  7. I knew that his congratulating of the Democrats would be too good to be true.
  8. I want to say to him "You know what? maybe you're right this "election" not being honest. If it wasn't for the cheating that you and party did over the past 2 years including you and your party's widespread disenfranchisement and denial of voting rights, widespread gerrymandering, illegally throwing away hundreds of ballots, etc. then the Democrats would've won by A LOT MORE!"
  9. Don't worry about that. Unchecked capitalism is only going to get worse and worse until we either have an incredibly massive strike on the elites or we have another Depression on the order of the 1890s or 1930s.
  10. I would agree with that. As would Lincoln and TR.
  11. Yeah, I am made a thread about this a few years ago:
  12. Couldn't agree more! In fact, I thought about making a thread like this on here. Everybody has to read and study up on the history of mass movements such as the labor movement, the abilition movement, the civil rights movement, the Jewish Reform Movement, the Indian independence movement, the feminist movements, etc. Also, we became more atomized because the places that once bundled people together such as big workplaces, unions, churches, temples, local civic groups, dense neighborhoods, meetings in libraries, and shared local media, all weakened at the same time, while work, housing, media, and daily life became more dispersed and individualized. We need to rebuild all of those civic institutions in order to most effectively restore that solidarity our country used to have in the 1900s, especially in the mid 1900s.
  13. Then, why do most people say that they are sick and tired of Congress, the establishment, and the institutions not working for them? The early 1900s progressive era programs, the New Deal, the Great Society, and so on were able to fundamentally change the system from a more unjust laissez-faire kind of capitalism into the most regimented, most free, and most fair version of capitalism we ever had. We can and must make US capitalism into more of a social democracy. Otherwise, there could be untold national instability that we have never seen before including another 1890s depression or Great Depression. Also, if the capitalism is only going to worse, not better then why did these newly elected Democrats bothered to run on fixing income inequality, ending corporate domination, busting monopolies, and ending corporate lobbying? What would even be the point of having Democrats in power again if they are just going to nibble around the edges again and do useless hearings and investigations on Trump, the Republicans, big-tech, oligarchs, and what have you that won't lead to anything?
  14. You mean incremental progressive-leaning changes to the extent that were made during Biden's presidency? What the results of these midterms have shown is that the people aren't just rebuking Trump and his party. They have also given a major middle finger to the entire establishment. People want real change to the system, because they are getting sick and tired of the system not working for them.
  15. I didn't say that these areas will be permanently blue, but they should be competitive for the long-run. Republicans can't dominate the South forever. In fact, Democrats used to dominate the South for nearly 90 years before Republicans eventually dominated it. Like you've talked about before, nothing lasts forever, and progress in the long-run doesn't stop. Yeah, I get what you're saying about how capitalism is never going to be fixed for decades. But do you think that the Democrats won't get anything done at all even if they win back the presidency in 2028?