-
Content count
1,285 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Anton Rogachevski
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Are you a Joker of some sort? I've worked on this essay for two days straight now, I think I might be obsessed! Anyway, it's way more concise and polished now, you would love it. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@UnbornTao How do you define "truth", what do you expect it to look like? What do you think a breakthrough is? Is a detailed description of experience satisfactory for you? In what way would you like to "know" experience? Yep it really was a deep contemplation! The text is meant to be a guided live contemplation and a direct observation of experience as one reads it. Thank you for the feedback dear friend, Cheers -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@theleelajoker Sounds cool dude! Did you really go to a Guru? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
There is an old saying in the text "You sometimes need a thorn to take out another thorn." (I'm paraphrasing) So it's not so simple, if it were, Buddhism and all the other spiritual traditions wouldn't exist and everyone would just be enlightened. In my opinion a basic conceptual understanding of this is pretty good to have. A conceptual framework is somewhat like a fishnet, and just like with catching fish, you need some tool to apprehend the ethereal spiritual experience, or else you'll simply return empty-handed. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
So you must like Leo famous "Look at your hand and shut up" I think a complex brain likes complexity and that's pretty simple. Nope still not. hint? Do you want this at the top? to set intentions? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@theleelajoker Thank you very much for feedback it's pretty masterful I would say! I'll try to apply some of it right now. You didn't like the brain example? I thought that it was a pretty cool and paradoxical example of how the ideas are not the same as reality. That would be a bit of a spoiler wouldn't it? If only it were that simple. Simplistic answers are not as satisfying in my opinion. Maybe for some it works. Isn't that useful for avoiding misleading ways in which it can be interpreted? I think it saves time to know these things instead of getting lost in ideas. New part to explain more: Without some degree of darkness there wouldn't be any manifestations because the Void is pure light, and just like in a projector you need to filter that light through film that covers some light partly to even have a picture. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@UnbornTao One may not, as there's nothing to grasp there. ------------------ I think we've pretty much beaten the poor horse to death. Are you satisfied with the dept of contemplation? Were you aiming at something in particular? Do you think there's more to be found here? On that note I must recommend for you to read my comprehensive and detailed Non-Duality guide with no bullshit and very detailed explanations. It's quite a read, but I promise it will be worth it. I've recently revised and refreshed it with new insights and made it even more clear and epistemically humble and accurate. I think that it will help shed more light on this very ethereal nuanced subject that also involves experience as it's main substance. I would be very honored to hear your opinion about it. Cheers -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@UnbornTao Are you directly conscious of that process you are describing, or is that an idea about that process? -
The fallacy of thinking that if there's a word for it, then it must exist somewhere as category, object or as phenomenon. It plays somewhat with confirmation bias. If you think it's insignificant, just imagine for a second a word like "god". How many people actually falsely and blindly believe there must be an entity somewhere since all the religions are shouting this word. All Words are ape noises pointing nowhere.
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@UnbornTao So my question for you is what is the difference between experience and direct experience? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Beautiful! -
@Leo Gura Thank you for your response, I really appreciate that you try your best to answer all the comments. I hope you can see that this is debate and it seems that this process must be in debate form because that's how minds operate. They need to be convinced by a powerful and coherent argument. I do find your statements to be a bit optimistic about the scope of their application beyond Phenomenology, the field that I find most fascinating and it's quite enough for me to focus on and really dig deep into the basic epistemic tool that is the mind. I believe that this is foundational to any intellectual persuit. What is your vision for science? How would it look different if your insights are applied?
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Do you know with a 100% certainly that this is the case? Where is this world? From what authority do you purpose these claims? Do you understand how extravagant your claims are? You talk as if you know actual Truth. Is it the case? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Haha yeah, but then we wouldn't have had so much fun playing around with these amazing and fundamental ideas. I feel most alive when I'm in such a conversation and deep contemplation. It's really a pleasure! So thank you again. When had "being" entered the conversation? What is that? How does it relate to experience? How does activity affect what "I actually am"? Isn't that a noise an owl makes? I don't know what that word signifies actually. It seems that it supposes a world where there are "beings" - when you think you are a "self" you imagine other "selves" too. I told you, presumably an ape like creature on a floating rock out in space. What did you not like about that answer? Of course there are accepted intersubjective ideas we all agree on and understand quickly and easily, that's not the point. We are not talking about being pragmatic here, we are trying to dissect phenomenon, and to see how "reality" is being constructed on the go, and how the brain takes that construction to be "real". I would give you that pencil in the physical realm, but what actually would occur there phenomenologically speaking would be ineffable. Think of them as two realities happening simultaneously: The physical occurrence of materials and biological creatures, and what those creatures perceive within their brain simulated experiences and the seamless way in which the brain is labeling all the objects and persons within that simulation. Can you see that in the physical there was an actual object, but inside the mind it's an experience shadow with an idea of a "pencil" attached to it? From a phenomenological perspective there is no "pencil", just experience: colors, sensations of touching, sounds, idea labels, "self" concept, "other" concept - these are the building blocks of experience. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Yeah Yeah's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@kbone We shouldn't compare ourselves to each other as every case is special in its own. Thank you dude, Cheers -
@Leo Gura "Science" (I say it like that because there's no actual entity that this label may be sticked on) has made a very clever trick by separating itself from Philosophy entirely, it's own mother. On the other hand, it's not even interested in Truth, it's goal is accurate prediction and not truth seeking - So what do you want from it? It's not promising you Truth. Science doesn't deal with "what it is, but rather "how it is" - an accurate description of its behaviour. Please explain, what is your quarrel with Science exactly? You say that reality is undefinable, I agree, and so do they, so they just skip this step and go on with progress. I'm sorry, but to me it seems a bit like you are fighting with windmills.
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Physics are important to phisicists, so I leave it to them. I look deeper into phenomenology because that I have true access to and that's the most important thing for an experiencing being. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Pure Awareness phenomenologically speaking, but presumably an evolved ape like creature that thinks it's a "human". You are just finding another synonym or a different way to say the same thing and pretend it's a new and separate phenomenon. It's a mind trick. You want there to be a "self", because it's scary to not exist. Various degrees of consciousness, but the substance is the same. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
The brain learns to automatically layer language on top of experience so well that it seems like it's a part of the thing. If we go back to our other discussion we can see why: language is also made from experience! just like everything within experience. Yep it's funny how we automatically assume we all talk about the same thing when we say "love", but there are as many definitions for it as there are people. It's a process of deep learning. The first primate kept pointing at a thing, and said "uga buga" multiple times, and eventually the brain of the other primate understood finally that "uga buga" means the thing pointed at - or at least I presume as it's hard to tell really. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Yeah, thanks for the correction How are they not the same? How do you see the difference? Of course not. The one is happening now, and the other is a recollection. Conceptual understanding is happening so seamlessly it seems almost real. That's what is meant when saying one is "building castles in the skies", it starts to feel like ideas are coming alive and feel more real than the senses. Yes exactly! Phenomenologically speaking the thing we perceive as "ourselves" is another experience not different from a coffee table, but because of its proximity (a feeling of presence) and the bodily sensations we attach to it, we think it's a different or a more "special" experience than all the rest. There is no "perceiver" inside the simulation, we can't be aware of the True Perceiver which is our brain out there. (Not the idea of a "brain" within the simulation.) Because of how perception is built it cannot perceive the perceiver, but only experience. The same way the eye can't look at itself directly, but can see everything. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@kavaris I'm sorry but I'm not quite getting what you are trying to say. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Do you have access to reality? How do you know that? I think that only the mind's imagination can be infinite, and that has nothing to do with actual physical space. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@Reciprocality Presumably our experience feed is modeled online seamlessly immediately every moment by past experiences so yes it's very hard to not see a "chair" when looking at one. In that sense our brain is very much like a deep learning algorithm that just recognizes things. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Beautiful idea. It's ontology is unknowable in my view, as I only have access to the substance of experience and that is made of pure imagination. The process of forming memory is the conscious presence, usually emotional stimuli and openess to receive at that moment, or such a strong stimuli that simply leaves a scar. There is a function of the brain, that when functions healthily, puts a mental label that allows us to tell apart memory from present experience. This process is mixed well so seamlessly that the transition is not always obvious to the experiencer. Like you said intensity and the generated sane feeling of "realness" play a huge role here. We take memory so for granted, but without it we couldn't realize anything and much less communicate at such a level of abstraction. That said pure experience is still beautiful and mystical! -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Dodo's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@Dodo They probably do, but if you look from within experience "Other" "different" "separate" "minds" theses are all ideas, and so it seems like only your mind exists and the "others" you imagine. (It only seems that way) That's what happens when you apply non-dual(phenomenology) insights to ontology. These two don't mix. We should leave ontology to physicists. Why do people still think that mystical experiences reveal the nature of reality? They only reveal the nature of personal experience. Before going into non duality I think we should get our epistemology straight. How do we know things? What does it mean to know? How can truth be accessed? What is Truth? What is real? A good ol' philosophical argument! Valid.
