something_else

Member
  • Content count

    3,444
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by something_else

  1. I find it a bit ironic that you’re criticising Xonas for only responding to part of your argument because this is something I feel you often do too, lol But to address your last reply in the context of this thread and age gaps: Pretty much your entire argument has been based around Stage Orange values. Wealth, status, attractiveness, lifestyle and what each person can offer the other. Whenever someone brings up the less transactional components of relationships, you tend to bring the discussion straight back to transactional value. At least until this final comment where I feel you are actually agreeing with my underlying point, but framing it as a disagreement. Here you are hinting at deeper compatibility and emotional intelligence being important to a relationship, which I completely agree with. That’s kind of been my point all along. A successful 40 year old man might have a lot to offer an 18 year old girl in terms of lifestyle, financial security, experiences, etc. But that doesn’t necessarily mean the relationship is healthy or that they’re particularly compatible. And when there’s a significant difference in maturity, life experience and power, there are other dynamics worth considering beyond whether both people are getting something they want out of the relationship. I’m not arguing that age-gap relationships are inherently unhealthy, I’m just arguing that your framework for evaluating them is typically far too limited.
  2. Like yes obviously providing value is important for a relationship, but reducing everything to it will leave you miserable and alone once the hollowness of value-based market dynamics inevitably become apparent. For example, what if you hit a rough patch financially and your partner leaves you? What if your partner decides your wealth isn’t enough for them anymore so they upgrade to someone with more money? What happens when your beauty fades as you age so your man trades you in for a younger more ‘valuable’ model? Can you really say that’s functional and healthy? Because this is what a primarily value-based approach to dating looks like. Always on the lookout for a better deal. ‘Value’ in the stage Orange sense is ultimately quite hollow and temporary by its very nature and it’s not a great basis for a functional long term relationship. Again, I am not saying it isn’t important, it is, but it should not be the primary focus if you are looking for a healthy, happy and stable long term relationship.
  3. Right, but wanting to date a more established man doesn’t necessarily mean the relationship will be healthy or functional. Obviously, they’re two consenting adults so they’re free to make their own choices. The question is how likely it is to be functional and healthy in the long run. Take an established 35 year old man specifically seeking out 18 year old girls. Or even flip the genders. Do you really think that’s likely to produce a healthy relationship? Think Leo DiCaprio’s pattern of dating younger women, then dumping them for the next 18 year old once they reach 25. Many of those women may fit the description you’re giving, but that doesn’t negate the dysfunction caused by such a significant gap in maturity and power. I’m not saying these relationships can’t work. My point is simply that consent alone doesn’t make a relationship healthy, and such a large age and power imbalance makes a healthy dynamic less likely.
  4. I don’t doubt that, but this is not the life of the average 18 year old almost anywhere in the world. By and large, 18-21 year-olds are going to be spending time with other 18-21 year-olds. Of course there are exceptions, but we’re talking about averages here. Seeing a few 18-year-olds on a yacht and generalising from that to how people in that age group typically socialise is flawed reasoning. Your average 18-21 year-old friend group probably doesn’t want a 35-year-old regularly hanging around with them. And the average 35-year-old probably doesn’t want to spend their free time hanging around with a bunch of 18-year-olds either. I’m not saying these social circles never overlap. I’m saying that the examples you’re describing are exceptions rather than a representation of how most people actually socialise. And you don’t address the main point I’m making either, which is that regardless of how and who you socialise with the difference in maturity and life experience between a 35 year old and an 18 year old is vast, far too vast to build a solid relationship in most cases. The social circle is just one example of that, but there is no shortage of others. On average: 18 year old has little or no prior experience being in relationships 18 year old has little or no financial independence 18 year old has a much less developed sense of personal identity 18 year old has little experience with conflict resolution 18 year old has little experience with independence 18 year old has little experience with long term planning And this list took me about 30 seconds to come up with, I could keep going.
  5. These are closely and intricately linked.
  6. Men are emotionally abusive too. It’s not unique to women. And the rates of physical abuse towards women are still pretty high too.
  7. Because a man in his 30s and a girl who is 18 have essentially zero shared life experience upon which to build a functional relationship. Imagine the 18 year old going to high school or college parties and bringing her 35 year old boyfriend along? Or the 18 year old coming along to weddings with the 35 year old? The typical social lives of these two people is quite incompatible. You would struggle to merge your lives together in a way that is required for a healthy relationship to blossom. If they wanna fuck and it’s consensual without any fucked up power dynamic? Sure, go for it. But building a functional relationship with that kind of age gap, where both people are at such fundamentally different parts of their lives? Very hard to make it work. On top of that it’s pretty likely that the 35 year old trying to date 18 year olds is aiming to abuse the power and development disparity, so there are potentially ethical concerns too. When you fully enter the adult world around 23-25 it becomes more doable. A 25 year old and a 40-50 year old for example is more doable despite the age difference being larger. It certainly wouldn’t immediately raise red flags purely for the age difference like it would with an 18 year old. Though it obviously is still much more likely to be dysfunctional than a smaller age gap relationship.
  8. The chance of dysfunctional power dynamics definitely increases with age gap. It’s basically impossible for an 80 year old and an 18 year old to ever have a functional relationship, for example. Honestly it’s probably even pretty close to impossible for an 18 year old and a 30+ year old to have a functional relationship. With something like a 25 year old and a 50 year old it’s very much on the line. Possible to be functional? Yes. But likely to be functional? Not at all So age gap can serve as an indicator of dysfunction, even if it isn’t always a guarantee.
  9. We have these too, most still do a very thorough assessment and are relatively regulated. At least here. I’m sure there are exceptions though if you hunt around for specific clinics that are a bit sketchy. Right, but if you want to solve this problem it is necessary to know what the root cause is. I’m glad this worked for you, but this is not guaranteed to work for everybody. If you’ve ever met someone with severe ADHD or Autism, eating anti-inflammatory food is not going to solve those issues. It may help to a degree, but it won’t solve them. What? I have no idea what you mean here Because kindergarteners have zero responsibility, so the impact of ADHD on their lives is fairly limited on them. Even in most of school, you don’t have that much responsibility so a lot of ADHD goes under diagnosed, especially in women. This is particularly relevant for the inattentive scale of ADHD which produces daydreamers, versus the hyperactive scale which produces the stereotypical chaotic badly behaved kids.
  10. Also, to be clear, I agree diet exercise and sleep are all important. But you have to understand that maintaining these things can be incredibly difficult if you have broken reward circuitry from something like ADHD. In many cases, meds significantly help those with ADHD maintain consistent healthy habits.
  11. Where was this? In most of the Western world, ADHD assessments are pretty thorough, and one of the defining characteristics is that symptoms must have been present before around age 12. If that’s not the case, they’re unlikely to attribute your issues to ADHD and will instead look at other explanations, like lifestyle factors. In your friend’s case, it’s entirely possible he got a legitimate diagnosis and, for whatever reason, medication just doesn’t work for him. That’s not particularly uncommon. There’s also a bit of a chicken-and-egg problem with ADHD and dopamine. Dysfunctional reward circuitry → seek dopamine → eat tasty food → potentially worsen reward regulation → seek more dopamine → eat more shit food, and so on. So you have to ask whether his dysfunctional reward circuitry is causing him to eat like shit, or whether eating like shit is contributing to the dysfunction. What’s the root cause? In my case, I’ve eaten pretty well throughout adulthood and always exercised consistently. Yet I still couldn’t reliably get the things I needed to do done, or maintain focus on anything I didn’t find particularly engaging. This was a massive problem at work, where I’d constantly jump between tasks and make silly mistakes. Since starting medication five months ago, I’ve been promoted, and several coworkers specifically highlighted in my recent feedback that my work and mindset over the past six months have been outstanding. I rarely make silly mistakes anymore, and I’ve been working on a single long-term project for three months without losing motivation. So I kind of struggle to see the downside. I was already a healthy person with a solid routine, yet no matter what I did, I just didn’t have the focus or mental bandwidth to achieve what I wanted to. Medication has made that possible. I struggle to see any explanation other than ADHD in my own case, especially considering I had most, if not all, of the markers of inattentive ADHD throughout childhood, going back to around age seven.
  12. This is like saying “Autism? That’s just bad social skills. Have you tried talking to people?” The problem with the “just use willpower” argument for ADHD is that the part of your brain that is responsible for willpower is dysfunctional. Imagine it took you 5x the willpower just to do basic tasks like go for a walk and eat healthy, and how exhausting that would be over time. And while diet and exercise definitely help, the single biggest factor impacting the effects of ADHD is sleep quality. Also, plenty of people with ADHD are quite well behaved as kids, especially if they’re more on the inattentive side of the spectrum vs hyperactive, so that immediately discounts your final theory. All of this is to say, respectfully, you don’t really know what you’re talking about.
  13. Jesus christ dude. I almost have sympathy for how emotionally fucked up you are. But I’m also thinking more and more that you’re just trolling. It feels like every post is specifically crafted to produce outrage, but not be so wild that it becomes obvious you’re trolling. Regardless of whether that’s true or not, the first sentence of this reply holds.
  14. I think that’s fair. I’m not entirely convinced you’ve left that behind though, at least from the impression I get on this forum
  15. What are the bad parts that you have left, in your opinion?
  16. Same. The analogy I’d use is that for most of my life, I’d choose to dig six oddly shaped 1ft-deep holes instead of one perfectly rectangular 6ft-deep hole. The gravedigger analogy, lol. Maybe occasionally I’d manage to dig an almost rectangular 3ft hole, but I’d never quite follow through enough to produce that neat, solid 6ft hole that so many other people seem capable of digging. And that becomes a huge problem when life requires you to do one specific thing, do it well, and see it through to completion. Like, you know, an actual gravedigger would be expected to do. It feels good to tell yourself, “Well, being a generalist with a wide range of knowledge is valuable too.” And to a degree, it absolutely is, depending on the field you’re in. But it comes with sooo many downsides. Most notably, you end up coming across as a smart person who knows a lot about a lot of things, but has relatively little to show for it. Everyone assumes you should be successful because you seem knowledgeable and capable, but in practice, that knowledge is often spread so thinly across so many things that you struggle to turn it into anything that provides sustainable long term value to others. On meds, I can actually get things done to completion, for the most part. I can consistently dig a 5 or 6ft hole and make it pretty neat and tidy. And the nice thing is, I haven’t lost the ability to dig a few random 1ft holes along the way, just for the fun of exploring. I can still indulge that curiosity, but it no longer has to come at the expense of actually finishing the thing I set out to do. On another note, I suspect the polymaths of old still had massive follow through. I’ve met people with this polymath kind of mindset today, and they’re as far from ADHD as possible. They start one project, see it through to completion, then start the next and see it through to completion. And they never stop. Over time they build up such a wide array of deep knowledge, but it’s not done in this “jumping around” manner we get from ADHD. It’s built through consistency, follow through, focus, and execution applied to a wide variety of fields. And somehow they maintain the energy and consistency over time. It’s insane to me. The two people I have met like this seem borderline superhuman to me. Everything they touch turns to gold.
  17. What meds did they prescribe you at the time? A couple of my friends who tried the classic ADHD meds like Ritalin and adderal found them too intense, but had excellent experiences with Vyvanse (lisdexamphetamine). It’s a slow release pro-drug that essentially converts into stimulants slowly in your bloodstream over 14hrs, so it doesn’t have that intense hit feeling. For first week or so it can have that, but once you settle down into it it’s a very subtle feeling you barely even notice, yet the benefits remain. I also cannot speak highly enough of it. I would go as far as to say it has changed my life in the past 5 months.
  18. What? This doesn’t even feel like you’ve read my last comment. And no, I’m saying that broadly speaking rates of dysfunction are comparable (though the evidence is not that definitive as far as I can see) when we exclude abusive relationships and when we ignore the degree of the dysfunction. When we include these, the rates and degree of dysfunction becomes extremely imbalanced towards women being the victim. What? “I’m not showing statistics because they prove the argument I’m making”? I’m so confused by this last reply.
  19. What makes you say that? With something like this you have to base your argument on stats over personal experience because basically no single individual has an unbiased sample large enough to generalise into an effective argument. If you had 3+ relationships with dysfunctional women that probably says more about you than it does about women. You would be the common denominator there. This argument can be used to criticise the woman here too, and like I said, that’s totally fair. But you cannot then say it’s unfair for her to generalise her small personal sample size to all men while in the next breath doing the exact same thing yourself.
  20. I think it’s fair to criticise her specifically, I don’t think your broader point of dysfunction in relationships being equal is as fair though.
  21. Congrats man!!!! I’m glad you had a good time. Not to taint your victory, but the pickup interpretations and terminology are a touch cringe, in my opinion you don’t need to call everything by its pickup name. Just say you were touching each other’s arms, not “doing kino” And I don’t think her asking “what is your plan” was a shit test. Do you think she was asking about your plans for this particular night, or about your general relationship plans? Both are just common questions a woman will ask you on dates. If it was the former, there’s a good chance she was giving you an opportunity to lead her towards home so you guys could have sex, or if you were already there she may have been trying to work out if you were going to stay and have sex, or if you were going to go home. If it was the latter she was probably trying to figure out whether you were looking for something casual or long term.
  22. I feel as though my comment below also answers this, so I’ll quote you too. But you cannot just select the subset of relationships that fits the narrative you want to portray and ignore the ones that don’t. Domestic violence rates are more even than you’d expect, sure. In 40% of cases (last time I checked) the victims were men, which is not a huge disparity. However if we look at severity stats (in my country, Scotland / UK), women are roughly 2x more likely to experience severe and sustained domestic abuse, 4.5x more likely to experience domestic sexual abuse or violence, roughly 2.5x more likely to experience stalking / controlling behaviour from an ex or current partner, and several times more likely to be killed by a partner too. These are not stats that you can just ignore. Especially when combined with general sexual assault or harassment statistics, it should be possible for you to empathise with why so many women feel this way about men, even if you don’t necessarily agree with one particular woman’s take. I am guessing this annoys you because you know that you yourself are not one of the men who would do this kind of thing, so you are being judged by the actions of other men and this feels (understandably) unfair to you. This is because you are a good man. It does not mean all men are good, and I think you should be able to empathise with women who have a fairly negative sentiment towards men rather than just dismissing them as crazy or biased.
  23. I mean… yes? I feel like that’s quite a reasonable thing to do.
  24. It is definitely balanced in favour of women. Men do some pretty horrific shit to women on average, worse than what women do to men on average. Not to say women are innocent in gender wars, of course not, but it definitely isn’t one of those cases where both sides are equally bad.
  25. @Emotionalmosquito Nice dude!!! It’s normal to be nervous, try not to overthink, don’t go in with an agenda, don’t go in with expectations. Vibe with her and have fun. Regardless of what happens, this is personal development and more experience, so enjoy that feeling. If there is flirty energy then you can invite her back to yours, some girls are down, some aren’t. Just don’t be too pushy about it, and try to slide it into the convo smoothly rather than just directly inviting her to yours. Good luck!!