Wilhelm44

Member
  • Content count

    3,395
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Wilhelm44

  1. "Legal sources told the Mail the jury's mixed verdicts will make it difficult to persuade appeal judges. One legal source told the Mail: In a way it would have been easier for Winter if there had been a clean sweep of guilty verdicts. At least then he could have argued that Brand did not get a fair trial because of the [Channel 4] Dispatches and Sunday Times investigation. The mixed verdicts show the jury reached their verdicts on the facts, regardless of the media attention, which makes an appeal very tricky. Brand's sentence of ten years and six months was also at the lower end of the ten to 15-year spectrum of possible sentences for his crimes."
  2. Yeah, different definitions of what self is.
  3. @Mellowmarsh Please can you answer this question from your experience. (The way I understand it is that personal identification with thoughts and emotions fall away, ie the sense of feeling incomplete/separate. But preferences and survival instincts and personality remains.)
  4. But for some it has. Different strokes for different folks I guess.
  5. But nothing specific in the evidence from the trial that was reported in the media ?
  6. The text messages don't mention rape specifically. No medical records of injuries were found. What specifically are you referring to ?
  7. I'm not saying people forget that they were raped. I'm asking how reliable would testimony from 20 years ago be, when the judge is trying to establish consistency of story etc
  8. The only part that really needs to be fabricated is the actual act of rape.
  9. Prevented was a bad choice of word. Jodistrict basically said brilliant acting could be rendered useless by catching the victim in a lie. And I'm saying when it comes down to the ultimate testimony, ie did he rape me or not, it's not really possible to catch someone in a lie there, because at that final point, it's he said she said.
  10. I'm playing devil's advocate. I mean no disrespect to the victims.
  11. Jodistrict was insinuating that a good defense lawyer good render brilliant acting useless. Go back a bit on this page to see.
  12. I was talking about the women. You said a good defense lawyer could prevent brilliant acting by catching the accuser in a lie. I'm saying that's not possible to do with regards to the actual act of rape itself, because only the rapist and the victim were present for that.
  13. But it would be impossible to catch someone in a lie with regards to the actual rape part.
  14. Of course, a lot of the evidence relies on the details though
  15. @Jodistrict Have you tried recalling the exact details of a sexual encounter you had 20 years ago. How would you rate the consistency and reliability of your own testimony in this regard ?
  16. Once again I'm not saying he's innocent. But I know for a fact that my wife for example, is such a brilliant actress, that if it came down to "Does it look contrived or is it gut-wrenching emotion", she could fool any jury.
  17. Although the jury don't give their reasons for a verdict, it's interesting to note the defense's argument in the Bournemouth rape case: (one of the 2 rape cases that was rejected) "His defense barrister, Ian Winter, argued that the 27-year gap made reliable proof difficult and contended that the complainant would have left the room if she had felt in danger, and that Brand had acted normally afterward." from Gemini An interesting experiment is to see if you can recall the exact details of a sexual encounter you had 20 years ago. It gets a bit blurry don't it. Pretty wild to think that this trial had to rely on consistency in testimony based off memories from 20 years ago.
  18. Of course, but if the concrete evidence (not sure of the correct term) was not strong enough on it's own, there is a possibility that demeanor of the witness (does it look contrived or is it gut-wrenching emotion) may very well have been the deciding factor.
  19. So basically it could have all boiled down to this in the end.
  20. Yeah, consistency in testimony based on memories from 20 years ago would almost be impossible We need psychics or remote viewers in the jury
  21. Thanks, yeah nothing in there about any further evidence found. No final decision to appeal has been made yet.
  22. I hear you. Where did you get information about the appeal, ie that new evidence has been found which contradicts the victim's story ?