Jodistrict

Member
  • Content count

    2,165
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Jodistrict

  • Rank
    - - -

Personal Information

  • Location
    San Diego
  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

8,740 profile views
  1. Your questions are flippant. Those women go through hell in cross-examination.
  2. How Cross-Examination Catches Lies Without Eyewitnesses Even if no one else was in the room during the incident, a fabricated story rarely exists in a vacuum. Defense attorneys use several methods to expose inconsistencies: Prior Inconsistent Statements. By the time a witness takes the stand, she has usually given multiple accounts—to friends at the time, to therapists, to police investigators, and in pre-trial statements. Defense lawyers compare every single detail across years of records. Even a skilled actor struggles to keep minor, unscripted details consistent when questioned out of chronological order. Surrounding Circumstances. Attorneys test the details around the event against objective facts. They check timelines, text messages, call logs, work schedules, building layouts, and travel records. In the Brand trial, for example, Brand's legal team specifically used physical photographs of a venue's bathroom to challenge one woman's account of the space. Cross-Contamination and Motive. Defense lawyers scrutinize whether witnesses knew each other, read the same media reports before going to the police, or stood to gain financially. Brand’s defense explicitly argued that the complainants' memories were contaminated by the 2023 media documentary
  3. Russell Brand is a professional actor. And according to the reports he was somber and not that great as testifying. Acting on a stage and testifying in a court room are two different things.
  4. If she has emotional scars she knows it wasn't consensual. It doesn't go away after 20 years. It's just specific facts that may be forgotten, like the exact order of events, color of the room, etc.
  5. Not if your defense attorney is good at cross examination.
  6. Good summary but also at the demeanor of the woman's account. Does it look contrived or is it gut-wrenching emotion when recalling the events. Only the jury sees this.
  7. That's why I suggest people educate themselves because the legal definition of "evidence" is the only one that counts.
  8. https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/russell-brand-appeal-conviction-rape-sentence-sacks-lawyer-b1305806.html
  9. Your phrase "conclusive evidence" doesn't have any legal meaning. It's Internet nonsense. Educate!
  10. No its not a cop out, it’s a suggestion that you educate yourself. The point you are missing is that only the jury saw all of the evidence in its context, including the demeanor of the witnesses (the trial wasn’t televised). It is the jury alone that was given the authority to determine the facts. You are assuming you have enough evidence to make an intelligent decision and you don’t. The only valid criticism is whether the jury received inadmissible evidence. That will be handled by an appeals court. In this case, the judge was extremely competent so I would be surprised if he made any errors.
  11. These days you can ask your AI assistant to explain the basics of law to you. It took hundreds of years to form good rules of evidence in the English Common law. If I respond to you here, you are in argument mode and won’t hear it. You can put yourself in learner mode and come up with the answer yourself.
  12. Wrong. I am just mentioning this because it is better to educate yourself on the law than spread ignorant myths that are circulating on the Internet.
  13. There was also actual evidence in this case. Testimony is evidence.