Nivsch

@Karmadhi Nothing is compared to being alone with zero control on your life, utterly deffenseless and with no freedom of motion. A family in Gaza are in a far better initial position and the tents area is 99.9% safe.

@Karmadhi Honestly you can't compare the horror of hostage to anything else in this war which is in another league. But there is a place to argue about the price in human lives infront of the result. However a cold number comparison is not the proper way here. Add to the equation that part of the civilians allowed hamas to hide hostages in their homes and part of them are innocent. So yes there isn't a clear cut answer here, and anyway I think a hostage deal is needed.

🥰💛

In response to Smotrich's video in which he says we have to settle in Gaza.

@Raze Iran arms hamas and hezbollah and funded terror actions against Israelis abroad. They (the regime) want to choke Israel from all directions to eventually eliminate it.

@Raze The Iranian regime aspires to eliminate Israel. You don't need to be pro Israel to think that, just to listen to their statements directly.

Former head of IDF (2002-2005) and minister of defense (2013-2016) Moshe Ya'alon.

@Karmadhi With all the problems, empirically speaking IDF ratio (combatants : civilians) in this war is better than any other urban war against terror done in the past by any country.

Stop listening to addicted/depended costumers afftected by problematic pharmaceutical drugs. That is what you asked now.

@BlueOak I like the attitude of the Iranian people. They are very experienced in the consequences of lack of democracy, an experience that europeans are lacking, and have a significant initial advantage in their ability to foresee the dangers of their regime's proxies ideology and its potential to influence Europe too.

I also think it will be demilitarized at least at the beginning although they still have an armed security force that co-operates already with IDF for years to suppress hamas in this area.

The security is quite significant here. This evening the LGBTQ assembly with a different format this year together with a Hostages release demonstration.

Israel has to establish now a security belt surronding the strip 5km depth into Gaza area built with multiple kinds of obstacles and save itself the right to respond harshly for every provocation from the side of hamas, what will anyway make slowly the guarantees US give to Qatar and Egypt to dissolve during the time and the next round is only a matter of time because hamas won't change.

Right.

They couldn't. You won't forget your home you left after couple of decades, so too a nation won't forget its home after couple of centuries.

@Raze Too graphic to me 😰🔞 They can say how 'evil' Israel in their opinion is without such streching tactics, unless they are desperate.

I can go further and sum up the situation of Israel / Palestine in two words: survival forces. Given the Jordanian area Israel has occupied in 1967 a hugh mountainy area with a much higher strategical advantage in comparison to the much narrower much lower almost all plane corridor central Israel is built of - an occupation of at least the western part of West Bank by Israel is necessary and at the very least understandable. And that is what the pro Palestinian side is in deniel about in the opposite side of the equation. I can admit that you are also right in the sense that this occupation has definitely gone too far what then created the opposite problem and made Israelis too physically donimate in the west bank relative to the fair potential solution we had to go towards.

Both sides actions fuel the next response from the second side.

As bad as extremist settlers terror is, attacks on also defenseless people happen in every conflict.

If to put Oct7th aside which was an exceptional peak, this conflict is still far less severe than many other conflicts for example Russia-Ukraine, Sudan, Syria etc. And its called a conflict for a reason, not a one sided "abuse" as many love to draw it like in a dellusional way. Romanticising it too much is a trap preventing us to see this conflict's bi-directional nature.